Rose Gold Jewelry Vs. Rose Gold Plated Jewelry

Rose gold has become a favorite in the jewelry world for its romantic pink hue and timeless elegance. However, when purchasing rose gold jewelry, you’ll encounter two main types: rose gold jewelry and rose gold plated jewelry. While they may look similar at first glance, these two types differ significantly in terms of composition, cost, durability, and care requirements. Understanding these differences can help you make the best choice based on your style and budget.

What is Rose Gold Jewelry?

Rose gold jewelry is made from an alloy of pure gold mixed with copper (and sometimes silver, zinc, etc.). Copper gives the metal its distinctive pink hue (the higher the copper content, the deeper the pink) and makes it more durable than yellow gold and white gold of the same karat. Check out our Gold vs. White Gold vs. Rose Gold guide to learn more!

Rose gold typically comes in different karat grades, such as 14K, 18K, or 22K, which indicates the amount of pure gold in the alloy. Pure gold is 24K, so 14K rose gold contains 58.3% gold, while 18K rose gold contains 75% gold. (Calculation formula for gold content: Karat Value ÷ 24K × 100%.) Lower karat values offer greater durability – see our Karat Gold Guide for more details!

Features of Rose Gold Jewelry:

• Durable and Long-Lasting. Rose gold contains copper, which increases its durability and resistance to corrosion and oxidation, allowing it to retain its luster longer.
• Retains Its Color Without Fading. The color of rose gold is inherent to the alloy itself, so there’s no need to worry about it fading over time.
• Hypoallergenic in Higher Karats. Rose gold is generally safe for sensitive skin, especially in 18K or higher grades.
• Relatively Expensive. Rose gold jewelry becomes more expensive as the karat value increases (and thus the gold content).

What is Rose Gold Plated Jewelry?

Rose gold plated jewelry is essentially gold plated jewelry, typically made with a base metal such as brass, sterling silver or stainless steel coated with a thin layer of rose gold. The rose gold plating process offers the look of rose gold jewelry at a much lower cost. Check out our Gold Plated Jewelry Guide for more information!

Features of Rose Gold Plated Jewelry:

• Affordable. Rose gold plated jewelry shares the same appearance as solid rose gold jewelry but is significantly less expensive, making it an excellent choice for those who want the look of rose gold without the high cost.
• Durability Depends on Plating Thickness and Quality. The durability of rose gold plated jewelry depends on the thickness and quality of the plating process, which can vary from jeweler to jeweler. Thicker plating lasts longer. The karat value of the plating also affects durability – lower karat values tend to be more durable, but contain less gold.
• Higher Risk of Allergies. The base metal used in rose gold plated jewelry is not standardized and may contain various metals, some of which can cause allergic reactions. MollyJewelryUS rose gold plated jewelry is made with high quality sterling silver as the base metal, which is generally hypoallergenic.
• Plating Wears Off Over Time. Over time, the plating on rose gold plated jewelry will wear off and require replating – a common problem with all plated jewelry.

Rose Gold vs. Rose Gold Plated Jewelry Quick Comparison

Feature	Rose Gold Jewelry	Rose Gold Plated Jewelry
Material	Alloy of gold, copper, and silver.	Base metal (various) with rose gold plating.
Durability	Highly durable for a lifetime of use.	Less durable, prone to wear over time.
Price	More expensive.	Budget-friendly.
Color Longevity	Retains color permanently.	May fade or chip with use.
Maintenance	Low maintenance, occasional polishing.	Requires careful handling and periodic replating.
Skin Sensitivity	Hypoallergenic (especially 18K+).	Potential irritation if base metal contains nickel.
Weight	Denser and heavier.	Lighter

How to Tell Rose Gold Plated Jewelry from Rose Gold Jewelry?

Typically, rose gold jewelry is more expensive, heavier than rose gold plated, and marked with 14K and 18K.

If it is not convenient to evaluate these factors, you can use the following methods:

1. Observe Edge and Seam Colors:
   In detailed areas, rose gold plated jewelry may expose the base metal’s color, while solid rose gold jewelry will have a consistent color throughout.
2. Magnet Test:
   Hold a magnet near the jewelry. Solid rose gold jewelry will not be attracted to the magnet. If the jewelry is attracted, it’s likely rose gold plated. However, this test is not 100% reliable as sterling silver based rose gold plated jewelry will also not be magnetic.
3. Knocking Sound Test:
   When struck, rose gold plated jewelry sound is crisp, while rose gold has a sense of gold’s calm and heavy.
4. Scratch Test:
   This is the most direct method. Scrape a small area to expose the inner metal. However, this method will damage the jewelry. If necessary, choose an inconspicuous area, but avoid this method unless necessary.

Rose Gold vs. Rose Gold Plated Jewelry: How to Choose?

Solid Rose Gold? Yes! Rose Gold Plated Jewelry? Also yes! The final choice depends on your budget, style, and intended use, etc. If you’re unsure, follow me for a quick self-test.

Quick Questions:

1. Does price matter to you?
   A. Not very
   B. Yes
2. Do you care about the jewelry’s longevity?
   A. Very much
   B. Not at all
3. Do you plan to wear it regularly or only occasionally?
   A. Regularly
   B. Occasionally
4. Is the design timeless or trendy?
   A. Timeless
   B. Trendy

Results:

• Mostly A Answers: Solid rose gold jewelry is the better choice for you.
• Mostly B Answers: Rose gold plated jewelry is a better fit for you.

Reasons:

Rose gold jewelry is more expensive but offers higher durability and longevity, making it ideal for long-term wear and preservation. Timeless designs are worth the investment in rose gold, as they can last a lifetime.

Rose gold plated jewelry is a more budget-friendly option. It achieves the same aesthetic as solid rose gold, but will wear down over time. It’s perfect for occasional wear or trying out trendy designs that may go out of style over time.

How to Clean and Care for Rose Gold and Rose Gold Plated Jewelry?

To maintain the beauty of your rose gold or rose gold plated jewelry, follow these care tips:

Rose Gold Jewelry Clean and Care

• Regular Cleaning:
  Use a gentle jewelry cleaner or warm soapy water to remove dirt and oils. If the surface becomes oxidized or dull and cannot be restored through cleaning, consider polishing. (Avoid frequent polishing, as each session removes a small layer of the metal.)
• Avoid Contact with Harsh Chemicals:
  Keep away from bleach, chlorine, and other corrosive chemicals.
• Proper Storage:
  Store in a soft cloth pouch or a separate compartment in a jewelry box to prevent scratches.

Rose Gold Plated Jewelry Clean and Care

• Gentle Cleaning:
  Wipe with a soft, damp cloth after each use. Avoid abrasive tools that can damage the plating.
• Limit Exposure:
  Remove before swimming, exercising, or applying lotions and perfumes.
• Separate Storage:
  Store in a soft pouch or lined jewelry box to prevent scratching.
• Apply New Plating Periodically:
  Monitor the wear of the plating and apply new plating periodically based on wear.

Related FAQs

Can rose gold plating be added to jewelry?

Yes! Through gold plating, a base metal can be coated with rose gold, giving it the same appearance as solid rose gold jewelry at a more affordable price.

Which is better, rose gold or rose gold plated jewelry?

It depends on your needs. If you want an affordable option for occasional wear, rose gold plated jewelry is a great choice. For a long-lasting piece to treasure for a lifetime, rose gold jewelry is the better option.

Do both rose gold and rose gold plated jewelry fade?

Rose gold plated jewelry will, rose gold jewelry will not.

This is because rose gold plating relies on the rose gold plating alone to maintain its color, which is lost as it wears. And while rose gold itself is a rose-colored alloy, it may darken slightly over time due to oxidation, but can be cleaned to regain its original luster.

How to clean tarnished rose gold plated jewelry?

You can try using a professional cleaner. If the plating is thick enough, light polishing may help; otherwise, replating is the only option.

How long can rose gold plated jewelry last?

The lifespan of rose gold plated jewelry depends on the thickness and quality of the plating, as well as the frequency of wear and care practices. With proper maintenance, it can last six months or longer under normal use.

Can rose gold plated jewelry be repaired?

Yes, it can. When the plating wears off, a professional jeweler can replate the piece to restore its original appearance.

Why is rose gold jewelry more expensive than rose gold plated jewelry?

Rose gold jewelry contains gold as its primary component, which is inherently more valuable. In contrast, rose gold plated jewelry uses a lower-cost base metal, making it more affordable.

Final Thoughts

Both rose gold and rose gold plated jewelry have their unique appeal. Rose gold is a luxurious and durable option that can last a lifetime, while rose gold plated jewelry offers an affordable way to enjoy this romantic hue.

Whichever you choose, the warmth and timeless charm of rose gold never go out of style. ✨

Start exploring the rose gold jewelry you’ve been dreaming of at MollyJeweryUS today! Whether it’s an engagement ring, wedding band, necklace or earrings, all of our jewelry is available in rose gold and sterling silver with rose gold plating options!