Morganite and pink sapphire, two popular pink gemstones, are often compared due to their dreamy and romantic hues. Whether you’re choosing a gemstone for an engagement ring, necklace pendant, or other piece of jewelry, the choice usually comes down to beauty, durability, and price. In this article, we’ll take a deeper look at the differences between these two gemstones from these perspectives to help you make the right choice!
Some may argue that pink sapphire, as a precious gemstone, clearly outranks morganite, which is a semi-precious stone. However, determining whether a gemstone is right for you isn’t just a matter of value; there are many factors to consider. Morganite and pink sapphire each have their own unique charms, what is the difference? Let’s find out …
1. Composition
- Morganite: This gemstone is a type of beryl (Be₃Al₂(Si₆O₁₈)), which belongs to the same family of minerals as emerald and aquamarine. Its pink hue is due to the presence of traces of manganese ions.
- Pink Sapphire: A member of the corundum family (Al₂O₃), which also includes blue sapphire and ruby. Its pink color is due to the presence of traces of chromium ions.
Fun Fact: When the concentration of chromium ions in corundum is high, it takes on a vivid red hue, and when it reaches the red color criterion, it forms a ruby. Lower concentrations produce pink corundum, i.e., pink sapphire. This raises debate in the gemstone world about “whether pink sapphire qualifies as ruby”. While the International Gemological Association recognizes pink sapphire as ruby, in the U.S. it must meet a specific red color standard to be called ruby.
2. Origins
- Morganite: Usually from Brazil, Madagascar, and Mozambique.
- Pink Sapphire: Commonly found in Sri Lanka, Madagascar, and Myanmar.
3. Appearance and Color
- Morganite: Morganite is usually a soft pink, peachy pink, or slightly apricot tone. This color makes people feel warm and romantic and is perfect for those who like a smoother style.
- Pink Sapphire: The pink color of pink sapphires tends to be more vibrant and saturated, sometimes with purple or orange sub-tones, as opposed to the softness of morganite. These bold colors create a striking visual impact, ideal for those who love vibrant hues.
4. Clarity
- Morganite: Usually of high clarity, especially in the case of high-quality morganite, and is nearly eye-clean.
- Pink Sapphire: More likely to contain inclusions than morganite. Corundum is often formed with needle-like inclusions (e.g. rutile), and flawless pink sapphires are rare. The more saturated pink sapphire, the more inclusions.
5. Hardness and Durability
- Morganite: With a Mohs hardness of 7.5–8, it is durable enough for everyday wear.
- Pink Sapphire: Boasts a Mohs hardness of 9, making it exceptionally durable and suitable for everyday use, especially as an engagement ring.
6. Price
- Morganite: More affordable than pink sapphire, making it an attractive option for those seeking beauty on a budget.
- Pink Sapphire: Typically more expensive due to its durability, rarity and vivid hues. Natural untreated pink sapphires with vivid color and clarity are extremely rare and can be very expensive.
7. Symbolism
- Morganite: Its soft pink hues symbolize gentleness and enduring romance.
- Pink Sapphire: Long associated, sapphire with loyalty and wisdom, pink sapphire adds an element of romance, making it ideal for meaningful jewelry.
8. Treatment
- Morganite: Most are heat-treated or irradiated to enhance color.
- Pink Sapphire: Natural, untreated pink sapphires are rare. Most undergo heat treatment or irradiation to improve appearance.
Note: Heat treatments are generally stable and result from internal structural changes. Irradiation-treated gemstones may fade under prolonged sunlight exposure. The stability of each gemstone also varies. Treated pink sapphires are more stable than treated morganites.
9. Cleaning & Care
- Morganite: Requires regular cleaning and should avoid exposure to strong acids, bases, or high heat. Clean with warm water and mild soap.
- Pink Sapphire: Durable and easy to maintain, but still should be protected from impacts. Clean with warm water and a soft cloth.
Note: Avoid using steam or ultrasonic cleaners for morganite. Pink sapphires can usually withstand these methods unless treated.
Quick Comparison Table of Morganite vs. Pink Sapphire
| Aspect | Morganite | Pink Sapphire |
|---|---|---|
| Gem Family | Beryl Family | Corundum Family |
| Color | Soft pink, peach hues | Bright pink, sometimes purplish |
| Origin | Brazil, Madagascar, Mozambique | Sri Lanka, Madagascar, Myanmar |
| Clarity | High, minimal inclusions | More inclusions, rare eye-clean |
| Hardness | 7.5–8 | 9 |
| Durability | Good, suitable for daily wear | Excellent, ideal for frequent wear |
| Price | Affordable | Higher, especially for natural gemstones |
| Symbolism | Romance, gentleness | Loyalty, wisdom, enduring love |
| Treatment | Heat/irradiation, common | Heat/irradiation, common |
Morganite vs Pink Sapphire: Which Gem Right for You?
Honestly, it’s up to you.
We recommend Morganite if ……
- You prefer soft, delicate colors.
- You want a romantic yet budget-friendly option.
- You wish to convey warmth and romance.
Opt for Pink Sapphire if ……
- You want a bold, vibrant gemstone.
- Durability and longevity are key factors.
- You’re willing to invest in a timeless, high-quality piece.
- You want to endure lasting and loyal love.
Whether you choose a morganite or a pink sapphire, you’re sure it will bring you joy!
Related Reading: Morganite vs. Pink Diamond: Which is Better for You?
Related Q&A.
Yes. Pink sapphire is rarer, making it significantly more expensive than morganite.
Pink sapphire. With a hardness of 9 on the Mohs scale, it surpasses morganite, which has a hardness of 7.5–8.
It depends on personal preference. Some people love the softness of morganite, while others prefer the vibrant brilliance of pink sapphire.
Both are popular. Pink sapphire, often considered an alternative to pink diamonds, has always been a favored choice for engagement rings and romantic jewelry. Morganite, with its unique appearance, has recently become one of the most sought-after options for engagement rings.
Not really. Morganite typically exhibits soft, pale pink hues, while pink sapphire often features bright and vivid pink tones.
Related Products
Explore more exquisite pink sapphire rings, pink sapphire necklaces, and morganite rings, or contact us for a custom-designed piece to make your vision come to life!